Why “Boy Crazy” Camila Cabello once cried at a Justin Bieber concert

There’s nothing like your first time—just ask Camila Cabello and John Legend.

Voice coaches played several rounds of a game called “My First Time” in honor of Camila’s upcoming freshman season on the NBC singing competition, and now E! News brings you an exclusive look at all the couple’s confessions.

As the clips below show, the game’s storylines ranged from Camila and John’s first passions to their own very various forays into the working world — the last of which is probably common knowledge among Camila fans. “My first job was a singer at The X Factor“, she said, referring to the series that became famous Fifth harmony. “I was 15!”

John, on the other hand, had a much more attractive first job: a repairman’s assistant at Kincaid’s Music Store in his hometown of Springfield, Ohio.