How Did Molly Dattilo Die? Was He Killed?

How Did Molly Dattilo Die?

Molly was the ninth and last child born in the family, and she spent her childhood in Madison, Indiana. The young woman possesses many skills, and she is a friendly, sociable, and reliable person. Molly is not only successful in the classroom, but also a talented athlete. As a result, he received a running scholarship to attend Eastern Kentucky University. Everything seems to be going well for the 22-year-old. He attended the Indiana University-Purdue University summer session in Indianapolis in 2004, with the intention of later submitting an application for “American Idol”. Molly’s day on July 6, 2004, began with the same routine as any other day. He shared an apartment in Indianapolis with his brother at the time, and they called that city home.

After getting some essentials and going to her lessons at around 7pm, Molly went to a nearby fast food restaurant to hand in her application for a position there. After that, Molly attends a party held at her apartment complex. Molly called her friend from a pay phone located at a gas station three miles from her apartment at approximately 11 p.m. Unfortunately, the call was cut off before the friend finished their sentence. After that, no one heard from or about him again. After more than a decade, Molly’s family finally officially acknowledged her death in 2017. However, the cause of death has yet to be determined.

What Really Happened to Molly Dattilo?

Molly came across a familiar face as she was on her way to the fast food establishment, and that person jogged their memory about the fact that she had her phone with her. After some time, the device was found inside his flat. At a party held at her building on the evening of July 6, 2004, she met John Shelton. Another of his close friends introduced him to her. Following their departure from the party, the two went on a boat excursion and then ate dinner at a Taco Bell, according to the inquiry’s findings. The call came in at approximately 11pm and was made from a payphone, located three miles away in the opposite direction from the apartment.

When John was later questioned, he admitted that he was with Molly at the time she called, but said he dropped her off at the house after the call. He was the last person to see him alive at any point in time. Nick, Molly’s brother, did not immediately report his sister missing because it was unusual for Molly to embark on unplanned trips. Nick believes that Molly is home safely. On the other hand, Nick became concerned when Molly still did not come home or contact anyone on July 8, 2004. He contacted the authorities, but they did not take his report seriously because they thought she had abandoned him. own will.

However, all of Molly’s belongings, including her purse, identification, car, and phone, were still inside the flat when the police arrived, leading them to suspect foul play. However, the authorities lack a large amount of information to track. The family continues to talk about Molly and her disappearance in hopes that other leads will emerge. According to the episode, two years after John’s disappearance, they decide to use a private investigator to find out more information about him. He has been in and out of jail for various offenses throughout his life.

When the family decided to make John’s name public, it was claimed on the show that his ex-girlfriends confessed to the family about how John made them feel uncomfortable and threatened them. They said John bragged about doing something to Molly and then threatened to do the same thing to them if they didn’t keep their distance. Some of the other women in the family described how, when he was drunk, he would strangle them. The fact that there was no body or any other proof made it impossible for the authorities to place John under arrest. In October of 2008, police were given additional information.

According to the program, the tipster claimed that John spoke to his father, Edward, the night of Molly’s disappearance and told him that he had accidentally killed someone else. In response, Edward asked him to find a suitable burial place for the deceased. Before long, the investigation into Molly’s disappearance was turned into a homicide probe by the authorities. John was the only person interested in the investigation all these years. In 2010, the family prevailed in a false claim against John and Edward, resulting in an award of $3.5 million to Molly’s loved ones. The Sheltons, on the other hand, failed to appear in court, leading the family to assume they would never see the money.

On the show, it is revealed that John is currently serving time for drug trafficking and armed robbery-related crimes, and that he will be eligible for parole in the year 2038. Molly’s family has decided to officially recognize his passing in September of 2017, assuming that he died on July 6, 2004. Celesta Dewey, his sister, said that “at this time, we are operating under the assumption that he has died.” Because of this, I don’t consider it a form of surrender. Even if someone is declared legally dead, that doesn’t mean you’re going to give up on finding them anytime soon.

The Mysterious Disappearance of Molly Dattilo

On Tuesday, July 6, 2004, Molly followed her regular routine and went to her courses. She went shopping that afternoon, mainly with the intention of buying a present for her young niece’s upcoming birthday, and she also wanted to drop off some job applications.

That evening, around 7:00 pm, Molly decided to walk to Wendy’s fast-food restaurant. He had a job application he needed to deliver to Wendy’s, which was about half a mile away from his home. When Molly was out for a walk or maybe at Wendy’s, she ran into a friend of her sister’s. They had a brief discussion for a minute before Molly broke away from them to go back to her flat.

After he got home, he went to a friend’s apartment, where he saw several other individuals just hanging out. Molly starts talking to a young man named John Shelton when she sees him walking down the street. John was successful in convincing her to take a boat ride with him on one of the smaller lakes located within the complex. It just so happens that John has the inside scoop on the apartments because his brother Benji works there as a maintenance worker. Benji helps John collect the boat, which is placed in a shed. After getting the boat, John and Molly go for a short boat trip.

Afterwards, they stopped at a Taco Bell for a quick bite to eat.

After leaving Taco Bell, they never returned to the apartments they were staying at. They did not stop when they reached the apartments and instead drove several kilometers in the opposite direction. Molly strongly suggests that John stop at the gas station owned by Thornton around eleven o’clock at night. No one knew why or where they were going at that time. Molly went over to a pay phone to call one of her friends.

Molly owns a mobile phone, but she didn’t have it with her at the time. And there are many hypotheses why this is the case, despite the fact that it can be caused by many different things. To begin with, there was the year 2004. Obviously, there were mobile phones back in the day, but they weren’t smart phones in the same sense as we understand the term today, and people didn’t always carry them around. Second, because he’s been on the move all day, it’s possible that his phone’s battery is low and needs to be recharged. Third, it’s possible that he thought he’d be gone for no more than a few minutes. It’s also possible that he just forgot.

Despite this, Molly was only a few miles from her apartment complex when she felt compelled to stop and use a payphone to call a friend. After being questioned about this communication later, the friend admitted that he had, in fact, received a call from Molly; however, the line was cut before Molly could speak. He just thought they were off at the moment; nothing seemed unusual about the situation.